🔗 Share this article

The author had recently started introducing her first picture book this summer when the event cancellations began. First, a Los Angeles bookstore called off her appearance after what Matari characterized as external pressure from area residents. A staff member who had booked the event refused to cancel it, and the bookstore fired her. Shortly after, a second staff member quit in solidarity.

Next was New Jersey. Watchung Booksellers in Montclair was planning to host her subsequent event but abruptly canceled, explaining in an official communication it was "to ensure the safety of our staff and patrons".

Root Cause for Such Upheaval

The children's book in Jiddo's Garden, a picture book about a young Palestinian girl learning about her cultural background through her family traditions, rooted in his own family customs from the region.

Three thousand miles away and a couple of months earlier, Safa Suleiman was traveling to Seattle for her first ever educational appearance for her first book. Her phone rang during her flight: the educational institution had canceled her visit because of a recent article on her website where she had shared details about her relatives being lost in Israeli airstrikes in the territory.

"I never saw myself in children's books growing up, and I was preparing to present my story with children who may never have seen themselves in literature either," the author stated.

Growing Trend of Restrictions

These experiences are representative of a wave of book restrictions that has spread through the United States since 7 October 2023, interviews with nine children's authors reveal. Canceled appearances, restricted materials, and coordinated harassment campaigns have proliferated through schools, public libraries, and retail stores, affecting authors who have either written about cultural heritage, have supported Palestinian rights, or been affected by the opposition merely because of their visibly Muslim identity.

Among the affected writers, the trend reinforces of an uncomfortable and peculiar reality: that their very existence is threatening, and presenting idyllic stories that represent their childhood – regardless of content – can prompt organized campaigns accusing them of promoting prejudice and hatred.

Research Findings on Cultural Stories

According to 2024 research by author and educator Nora Lester Murad, there have been 114 English-language children's books explicitly centering cultural stories exist for school-aged children. Statistics show an increase in the past decade – 44% of Palestinian children's books over recent decades were published between the past five years. However this increase comes from independent publishing, with 32% of recent titles self-published as traditional publishers remain cautious about acceptance.

"There's a clear attempt to reject the people," Matari explained. "Despite making progress this industry and there's increased representation being published, it's like … we cannot prevent people from reading your story. So they can stop people from getting to know you, or connecting the writers with the narratives that they create."

"Free expression isn't afforded to everybody in this country, especially if you're Palestinian," she added.

Banned Books Week

The first full week of the month is Banned Books Week in the United States and is a period designed to spotlight censored voices. Yet pro-Palestinian authors are discovering they're at the forefront of a new form of book restrictions, though the publications being contested don't advocate political positions or promote hatred. They tell simple stories of gardens and cultural symbols, of children exploring personal identity and cultural language, of family traditions maintained across generations, causing writers to realize that it's their existence that appears to be the issue.

"In addition to disconnecting us from our homeland and from our community," the author stated, "now they're trying to separate us from our narratives."

Legislative Actions and Government Regulations

What started with angry emails and sudden event cancellations is also becoming encoded in government regulations. Recently, the state's leadership the official approved a legislative package into law designed to combat prejudice and religious discrimination in educational settings. One new law creates an regulatory body and an oversight position, and requires districts to examine and take corrective action when "problematic material is used in educational settings or staff training".

Worry present in the community of children authors is that the vague language could be employed to categorize their books and their narratives as problematic, providing state officials legal cover to continue restricting Palestinian narratives from education, and possibly witness these limitations grow in additional regions and various institutions.

Author Experiences of Restrictions

Earlier this month, another author was contacted about an scheduled appearance at North Carolina State University in Raleigh, where she had been asked to discuss her book her cultural narrative and the censorship attempts against it. University administrators informed her that her book contravened North Carolina's compelled speech and balance mandates because it "doesn't show multiple perspectives to the narrative". The author could participate in the appearance, officials told her, but she was prohibited from presenting from her publication.

But it's hardly the initial instance with censorship this author had to face. Moushabeck reported five visits cancelled since 2023 and the threats became physical at her family member's school in Amherst, Massachusetts last year. "I was required to come at the institution at six o'clock and go in through the rear entrance with a security escort," the author explained. An acquaintance joined her for additional protection while school security and law enforcement were present. "I remember having to do my school visit and keep a smile on my face and remain composed, because I really didn't want my young relative to see that we were at risk."

Further Examples of Limitations

At Germantown Friends, a Quaker school in the city, Jamilah Thompkins-Bigelow was scheduled for an all-day visit to launch her publication Sister Friend – a tale about relationships between a African American child and a peer who practices her faith. Shortly before the recent appearance, school officials declared a postponement.

"Officials believed that in the time that we were in, it was a protective measure," the author remembered. Subsequently was months of rescheduling without confirmed plans, ending with contract termination in February 2024 after approximately Jewish parents requested the institution remain "a secure environment for particular students".

"I felt like the microscope was on me as soon as they realized that, oh, this is a Muslim author and she expressed views about the region," the author, who wears a hijab, explained. "There's pressure to demonstrate that you're not promoting of being an antisemite if you have any pro-Palestinian commentary. Even just saying, 'Here's a link to support children' – that becomes controversial."

Online Impact

Another writer faced comparable treatment previously when two of her planned school visits were called off, one in the Sharon city school district just days before the event.

The author, who writes youth literature and picture books, was scheduled to speak about her work when community members began flooding the institution with objections after reviewing promotional materials. But the subject matter of her writing {wasn't the issue|wasn